The Ultimate Binge-Watching Starter Pack for True Crime Addicts

It's 7 PM on a Friday. You've got nowhere to be, no one to impress, and a queue full of documentaries about people who made very bad decisions. Tonight is going to be perfect.

But you need the right setup. A true crime binge isn't something you just fall into — it's something you prepare for. Here's your starter pack.

The Uniform

First things first: you need the right outfit. And by outfit, we mean the softest, most comfortable thing you own that also broadcasts your intentions to anyone who walks in.

The Murder Shows And Comfy Clothes Tee is literally named after what you're about to do. At $22.95, it's cheaper than a month of the streaming service you're about to spend 6 hours on. Pair it with your most broken-in sweats and fuzzy socks.

The Blanket Situation

You need at least two blankets. One for warmth. One for hiding behind when the crime scene photos come up. A weighted blanket is ideal — it provides comfort and the gentle pressure of existential dread that pairs perfectly with cold case files.

The Snack Spread

Binge-watching without snacks is just watching. Here's the optimal spread:

  • Popcorn — the classic. Buttered, not that air-popped health stuff. This isn't a gym session.
  • Candy — something you can eat mindlessly. Gummy bears, M&Ms, or Swedish Fish.
  • Something salty — chips, pretzels, or cheese crackers.
  • A drink — wine if you're feeling classy, hot cocoa if you're cold, iced coffee if this is going past midnight.

The Watchlist

You need a lineup. Don't spend 45 minutes scrolling — have it planned before you sit down.

Documentaries

  • Making a Murderer — the one that started it all for most people
  • The Jinx — the ending still haunts us
  • Evil Genius — four episodes of pure chaos
  • Don't F**k with Cats — internet detectives at their most intense

Series

  • Dateline NBC — the comfort food of true crime. Keith Morrison's voice is a warm blanket.
  • Forensic Files — short episodes, perfect for "just one more"
  • Unsolved Mysteries — the reboot is genuinely good

Podcasts (for when your eyes need a break)

  • My Favorite Murder — Karen and Georgia are the reason half the internet owns a "murderino" shirt
  • Crime Junkie — clean production, addictive storytelling
  • Casefile — anonymous Australian host, deeply researched cases

The Phone Setup

Put it on Do Not Disturb. You don't need interruptions during a crucial witness testimony. The only acceptable notification is a text from someone asking "are you watching the thing about the guy?" Yes. You are always watching the thing about the guy.

The Morning After

You'll wake up on the couch at 2 AM with popcorn crumbs on your chest and your phone showing a Wikipedia page about a case from 1987. This is normal. This is the life you chose.

Grab the Murder Shows And Comfy Clothes Tee and embrace it. Or browse our Dark Humor collection for more shirts that match your personality.

Shop Dark Humor →

Back to blog